Several weeks ago I began an earnest attempt to “declutter” my space. It is really an ongoing effort. I culled my library of books. I brought to the thrift store a CD/tape player that my mother had given me at least 35 years ago. I gave my 12-string guitar to my godson (well, on ‘permanent loan’ let’s say!)—it deserved to be played more often. I scoured my office, amassing four bags of shredded paper, and every day for a week, I managed to find another piece of clothing or two I didn’t really need.
And that’s the struggle isn’t it? Need versus want? Even as a religious, I am such a daughter of my culture—colonial, imperialist, capitalist—culture, with its amazing gifts and underlying greed. In his latest book The Myth of Normal, medical doctor and author Gabor Maté calls this craving for what I don’t really need “consumption hunger.” He writes,
“Among the great achievements of mass-consumption culture has been to convince us that what we have been conditioned to fervently want is also what we need.” ¹
He goes on to share this steely insight written by Thomas Merton in 1948:
“We live in a society whose whole policy is to excite every nerve in the human body and keep it at the highest pitch of artificial tension, to strain every human desire to the limit and create as many new desires and synthetic passions as possible, in order to cater to them with the products of our factories and printing presses and movie studios and all the rest.” (The Seven Story Mountain p.148)²
Geesh! A little harsh, Thomas? But alas, quite true?
So, back to decluttering. Guilt has never been a motivator for me; it gets my engines going for about three weeks before the effort sputters to a halt and then dies a rather insipid death! Blah! So I thought I would try something different this time. I prayed. How novel is that? Yes, I asked for the grace of my vow of poverty to give me courage and freedom to let go; to loosen attachments, conscious and unconscious. It was a short prayer but sincere. Thomas Merton was known to say that a little sincerity goes a long way with God. I hoped that this was true. Now as I write this, I feel myself tearing up; clearly there is something more going on here for me.
I have much to declutter in my life… useless thoughts, unhelpful attitudes, long-held privileges, fears, false beliefs, many “things,” both inner and outer. I am quite aware that the consumption hunger and the need for control imbued in our culture, and therefore in me, causes great suffering in our human and more-than-human world. Consumerism, like other addictions, mutes our pain by acting as a distraction; it blinds us and binds us. In this there is no true freedom to be had and no true justice can be found. O, this Holy Decluttering—such a lifelong journey!
Sandra Stewart is a member of the Sisters of Our Lady of the Missions in Winnipeg. Originally from Windsor, ON she has spent most of her religious life in Manitoba but has also served in France, Senegal and Papua New Guinea. She holds a Masters degree in Pastoral Studies from Loyola University in Chicago, majoring in spiritual accompaniment from the Institute for Spiritual Leadership.
Presently she serves as a spiritual director, a facilitator of Centering Prayer workshops, and an advocate for social and environmental justice.
Sandra currently serves on her community’s province leadership team in Canada.
This is such profound sharing, Sandy, and the fact that Merton analyzed with such accuracy all those years ago…nothing new under the sun! I have had many a conversation with my sons, both when they were young and now as adults, about the importance of knowing the difference between “want” and “need”. I have also assured them that they CAN get stuff they “want”, not just stuff they “need” but must always be conscious of the difference. So, thanks again, for reminding us….!
Thanks, Kath, for your reflections. The more I reflect on this, I see that the deeper reality beyond ‘want’ and ‘need’ is “attachment.” Hmmm, it never quite ends, this journey.
Thank you Sandra for sharing your article oddly enough I have been doing some decluttering in my home today. I moved back to Winnipeg with my husband about 4 years ago. I am looking for a group of women that I can connect with & grow in my faith & journey to be more of whom I am created to be. I have been away from Winnipeg for several years & although I do belong to an AlAnon group here, I am missing the connection to other women . While I lived in Winnipeg I was active in workshops at a place called Jeanne Elizabeth House.My attempts to reconnect have not been fruitful. If by any chance you are able to point me in any direction I would be so grateful .Decluttering myself is very appealing to me as is Centering Prayer Workshops. Thank you for reading my request, thank you for taking the time. Thank you for sharing your wisdom.
Jo Anne Bates 204-694-7939 batesjoanne67@gmail.com
Thanks for your comments, Jo Anne. I will contact you through your email regarding your request.
A powerful reflection, Sandy, and so challenging of my own inner and outer decluttering journey. Thank you!
WOW Sandy! I have been working at “decluttering” for years and have had mixed success. Your wise reflection has shown me that this task involves something so much deeper than simply classifying the items into “Keep, Donate, Discard.” And, I’m sad to say I never thought of asking God for help in this! Thank you.