M&M’s, Snickers and Oreos??!! It was July 30th, the World Day of Trafficking Against Human Persons, and, on my webinar screen, Dominican sister, Brigid Clingman, had been outlining two of the significant industries that profit from child labour: chocolate and electronics.1
But not M&Ms’s, surely? One of my favorite candy snacks stands accused.
I am vaguely conscious of ethical concerns around the production of chocolate, one of the long list of ways I, ensconced in my all-too-familiar socio-economic space, find myself to be a complicit environmental/ human rights violator. Typically overwhelmed, I am used to naming my powerlessness in the face of it all, holding my guilt lightly, and carrying on. Today, however, as stark information and statistics make their way across my screen, my complacency shifts. The time has come to pay attention.
I am disturbed to learn of the recent filing of a lawsuit accusing chocolate giants Mars, Mondelez and Cargill
“of purposely dragging their feet to phase out the use of child labor, misleading the public about their efforts and condemning generations of children to a life of poverty and dangerous conditions.”
An international agreement brokered in 2001 was supposed to have ended child labour by 2005. Until today, however, successive generations of children in African countries such as Ghana and the Ivory Coast, from as young as four years of age, are forced to work up to 14 hours per day, using chain saws and machetes, applying herbicides and pesticides without protective equipment, carrying sacks of pods weighing over 100 pounds…. Their families systematically cheated out of fair prices for their crops, they don’t get to school.2
On occasions when my companion in community and I bring visitors to St. Patrick’s Cathedral at the heart of New York City, we stop to contemplate the replica of Canadian artist, Timothy Schmalz’s bronze sculpture, Let the Oppressed Go Free, the only monument to human trafficking in existence today.3
The image of St. Bakhita, herself once a slave, opening up the underground, releasing persons bound by sexual exploitation, forced labour and debt bondage is compelling. In Schio, Italy, the 20-foot original is installed near her remains. On October 5, 2023, on the University of Toronto campus, St. Regis College unveiled a full-size outdoor replica “to shine light on the dark world of human trafficking in Canada and throughout the world.”4 In the words of Pope Francis,
“Human trafficking will always exist if it is kept underground.”5
The July 30th webinar is winding down, and Brigid Clingman is responding to a question about what one person can do in the face of society’s oppressive structures. She uses the analogy of a snowflake – the weight of one snowflake is negligible, but, in the winter, tree branches break because of the combined weight of snowflakes. In other words, she goes on, if one person refuses to buy a Hershey bar, the world will not change. But, if all of us refuse to buy Hershey bars and let Hershey know we are doing so, we will change the world.6
I no longer reach out for M&M’s without a second thought. And filling up the Contact Us form on the Mars, Incorporated website is next on my to-do list.
1 Alliance to End Human Trafficking, “Working to End Labor Trafficking,” August 1, 2024, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cWV6fmMc0p4 .
2 Ryan Knappenberger, “Candy giants sued over failure to end child labor on chocolate plantations in Ghana,” Courthouse News Service,November 30, 2023, https://www.courthousenews.com/candy-giants-sued-over-failure-to-end-child-labor-on-chocolate-plantations-in-ghana/ .
3 St. Patrick’s Cathedral, “’Let the Oppressed Go Free’Sculpture,” accessed September 21, 2023, https://saintpatrickscathedral.org/let-the-oppressed-go-free .
4 Canadian Centre to End Human Trafficking, “Let The Oppressed Go Free,” 2023, https://oppressedgofree.com/ .
5 Zeus Legaspi, “’Let the Oppressed Go Free’ sculpture shines light on human trafficking,” Vatican News, June 28, 2023, https://www.vaticannews.va/en/world/news/2023-06/bronze-sculpture-human-trafficking-schmalz.html .
6 Alliance to End Human Trafficking (n 1).
Claudia Stecker is a Sister of Our Lady of the Missions (RNDM). She was missioned to the Philippines in 1997 and worked as an educator, first, in Cotabato, at Notre Dame University, and, later, in Manila, at Asian Social Institute. Her subject areas included pastoral sociology, leadership, music and education. Claudia was also employed by Kuya Center for Street Children where she took part in establishing a microfinance initiative among urban poor families. Over the years, Claudia served the congregation, too, in leadership, formation and finance management, returning to Canada in 2021. From 2023, she has been missioned to New York, USA, where she serves as a host community member in a LifeWay Network safehouse for women survivors of human trafficking.
The only chocolate I really like is a small mini-Mars bar after supper. Surely it’s not that part of Mars that’s involved in human trafficking!!??!
As you say: “The time has come to pay attention.”
Thank you for also including in your reflection the replica of Canadian artist, Timothy Schmalz’s sculpture, Let the Oppressed Go Free. Schmaltz makes a powerful statement about human trafficking – with which I am now spending time, and paying attention.